Empty Promises or Structural Constraints? A Critical Qualitative Inquiry into the Nature of BRICS Social Development Efforts in South Africa
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.18246110Keywords:
BRICS, Social Development, National Development Plan (NDP), New Development Bank (NDB), South-South Cooperation, South AfricaAbstract
In recent years, the BRICS bloc comprising Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa has emerged as a vital platform for South-South cooperation, shaping global governance and development agendas. This study examines the impact of BRICS collaboration on social development initiatives in South Africa, focusing on the nature, achievements, and challenges of BRICS-supported projects. Grounded in the Developmental State Theory, the research explores how these partnerships align with national development goals and contribute to social transformation. Using a qualitative, exploratory design, data were collected through semi-structured interviews with key stakeholders, including South African scholars specializing in BRICS relations and officials from the Department of International Relations and Cooperation (DIRCO), selected through purposive and snowball sampling. Findings indicate that BRICS collaboration has contributed significantly to infrastructure, education, and healthcare development, particularly through the New Development Bank (NDB) and knowledge-sharing initiatives. Successes include enhanced funding mechanisms and technology transfer, mainly from China and India. However, challenges such as bureaucratic inefficiencies, weak coordination among BRICS partners, and socio-political resistance persist. While BRICS initiatives align with South Africa’s National Development Plan (NDP) 2030, gaps remain in addressing unemployment, poverty, and inequality. The study recommends improving policy coordination, transparency in funding, and stronger public-private partnerships to integrate BRICS initiatives into local social frameworks. Overall, the findings suggest that with targeted reforms and deeper collaboration, BRICS can play a transformative role in advancing South Africa’s social development agenda and achieving long-term sustainability. Limitations include a small sample size.
Downloads
References
Abdenur, A.E. & Folly, M., (2015). The new development bank and the institutionalization of the BRICS. BRICS-Studies and Documents, 77-111.
Akoojee, S. (2016). Developmental TVET rhetoric in-action: the white paper for post-school education and training in South Africa. International journal for research in vocational education and training, 3(1),1-15.
Alden, C. (2017). New Actors, New Models, New Outcomes? African countries' engagement with China and other development partners in achieving the SDGs and Agenda 2063. New Actors, New Models, New Outcomes? African countries’ engagement with China and other development partners in achieving the SDGs and Agenda 2063.
Andreoni, A. & Tregenna, F., (2020). Escaping the middle-income technology trap: A comparative analysis of industrial policies in China, Brazil and South Africa. Structural Change and Economic Dynamics, 54, 324-340.
Azzarri, C. & Signorelli, S. (2020). Climate and poverty in Africa South of the Sahara. World development, 125,104691.
Biziwick, M., Cattaneo, N. & Fryer, D. (2015). The rationale for and potential role of the BRICS Contingent Reserve Arrangement. South African Journal of International Affairs, 22(3), pp.307-324.
Bless, C., Higson-Smith, C., & Sithole, L., S. (2013). Fundamentals of social research methods: An African perspective (5th ed.). Juta.
Bond, P. (2018). Can the BRICS re-open the “gateway to Africa”? South Africa’s contradictory facilitation of divergent Brazilian, Russian, Indian and Chinese interests. In Africa and the World: Bilateral and Multilateral International Diplomacy (pp. 403-431). Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Bond, P. (2020). South Africa and BRICS: A Critical Perspective on Development and Governance. Zed Books.
Braun, V. & Clarke, V. (2012). Thematic analysis. In H. Cooper (Ed.), Handbook of research methods in psychology (pp. 57-71). American Psychological Association.
Braun, Y. (2020). Lesotho's white gold: the political ecology of temporality and the economy of anticipation in resource extraction and large dam infrastructural projects. Journal of Political Ecology, 27(1), 853-876.
Bresser-Pereira, L.C. (2010). The global financial crisis and a new capitalism?. Journal of Post Keynesian Economics, 32(4), 499-534.
BRICS Information Centre. (2016). BRICS Labour and Employment Ministers Declaration: Quality Jobs and inclusive employment Policies. Federative republic of Brazil: BRICS Labour And Employment Ministers’ Meeting.
BRICS. (2018). Joint Statistical Publication. [Online]. Available: https://bricsrussia2020.ru/images/132/35/1323516.pdf [Accessed 10 June 2025].
Carmody, P. (2017). The geopolitics and economics of BRICS’resource and market access in Southern Africa: aiding development or creating dependency?. Journal of Southern African Studies, 43(5), 863-877.
Carmody, P. (2018). South Africa in the global political economy: The BRICS connection. In The geography of South Africa: Contemporary changes and new directions (pp. 223-227). Cham: Springer International Publishing.
Chen, H., Pan, J. & Xiao, W. (2020). Chinese outward foreign direct investment and industrial upgrading from the perspective of differences among countries. China & World Economy, 28(3), 1-28.
Chisholm, L., & Chissale, A. (2025). BRICS, sub-imperialism and education in Mozambique. Comparative Education, 61(2), 225-243.
Cooper, A.F. (2017). The BRICS’ New Development Bank: Shifting from material leverage to innovative capacity. Global Policy, 8(3), 275-284.
Creswell, J. W. (2014). Research design: Qualitative, quantitative, and mixed methods approach. (4th edn.). California: Sage Publications.
Dang, H.A.H. & Dabalen, A.L. (2019). Is poverty in Africa mostly chronic or transient? Evidence from synthetic panel data. The Journal of Development Studies, 55(7), 1527-1547.
de Wee, K. (2016). Is South Africa ready to be a developmental state?. Africa’s Public Service Delivery & Performance Review, 4(3), 488-502.
Diko, N., & Sempijja, N. (2021). Conduit for Economic Growth and Development? Exploring South Africa and Brazil’s BRICS Membership. Politikon, 48(3), 355-371.
Duggan, N., Ladines Azalia, J.C. & Rewizorski, M. (2022). The structural power of the BRICS (Brazil, Russia, India, China and South Africa) in multilateral development finance: A case study of the New Development Bank. International Political Science Review, 43(4), 495-511.
Fetters, M.D., Curry, L. & Creswell, J.W. (2013). Achieving Integration in Mixed Methods Designs, Principles and Practices. Journal of Mixed Methods Research, 4(4), 342–360.
Fourie, W. (2018). Aligning South Africa's National Development Plan with the 2030 Agenda's Sustainable Development Goals: Guidelines from the policy coherence for development movement. Sustainable Development, 26(6), 765-771.
Francis, D. & Webster, E. (2019). Poverty and inequality in South Africa: critical reflections. Development Southern Africa, 36(6), 788-802.
Ghafouri, R., & Ofoghi, S. (2016). Trustworth and rigor in qualitative research. International journal of advanced biotechnology and research, 7(4), 1914-1922.
Gomes, G.Z and Esteves, P. (2018) 'The BRICS Effect: Impacts of South–South Cooperation in the Social Field of International Development Cooperation', in Gu, J. and Kitano, N, (eds) 'Emerging Economies and the Changing Dynamics of Development Cooperation', IDS Bulletin 49.3, Brighton: IDS
Gu, J., Renwick, N. & Xue, L. (2018). The BRICS and Africa's search for green growth, clean energy and sustainable development. Energy Policy, 120, pp.675-683
Gumede, V. (2019). South Africa’s journey towards a democratic developmental state. Africanus: Journal of Development Studies, 49(2), 23-pages.
Hopewell, K. (2017). The BRICS—merely a fable? Emerging power alliances in global trade governance. International Affairs, 93(6), 1377-1396.
Igwenagu, C. (2016). Fundamentals of Research Methodology and Data Collection. LAP Lambert Academic Publishing.
Isheloke, B.E. (2020). BRICS challenges and opportunities: management’s perceptions in South Africa’s mining sector. Brics and Economic Development: A Multidisciplinary Perspective, 31.
Iwara, E.I; Abunimye, S.B and Akpanke, J.B. Poverty, Coronavirus Pandemic and New Framework of Statehood in Africa. European Journal of Social Sciences Studies, 2020, 5 (2).
Kapoor, N. (2020). BRICS and its future: The challenges of multilateralism. Observer Research Foundation.
Kgoale, P.T. & Odeku, K.O. (2019). Transformative mineral resources beneficiation intervention fostering local entrepreneurship in South Africa. Academy of Entrepreneurship Journal, 25(2), 1-16.
Khomyakov, M. B. (2018). BRICS and global south: Towards multilateral educational collaboration. Changing Societies & Personalities. 2018. Vol. 2. Iss. 4, 2(4), 329-350.
Kirton, J. & Larionova, M. (2022). The first fifteen years of the BRICS. International Organisations Research Journal, 17(2), 7-30.
Knight, J. (2021). A tale of two countries and two stages: South Africa, China and the Lewis model. South African Journal of Economics, 89(2), 143-172.
Knight, J. (2021). A tale of two countries and two stages: South Africa, China and the Lewis model. South African Journal of Economics, 89(2), 143-172.
Kornegay, F.A. & Bohler-Muller, N. eds. (2013). Laying the BRICS of a new global order: from Yekaterinburg 2009 to eThekwini 2013. Africa Institute of South Africa.
Kornegay, F.A. & Bohler-Muller, N. eds. (2013). Laying the BRICS of a new global order: from Yekaterinburg 2009 to eThekwini 2013. Africa Institute of South Africa.
Liu, Z., Wang, Z., Xu, M., Ma, J., Sun, Y., & Huang, Y. (2023). The priority areas and possible pathways for health cooperation in BRICS countries. Global Health Research and Policy, 8(1), 36.
Lumumba-Kasongo, T. (2015). Brazil, Russia, India, China, and South Africa (BRICS) and Africa: New Projected Developmental Paradigms. Africa Development, 40(3), 77-95.
Maijama, R., Musa, K.S., Yakubu, M. & Mohammed, N. (2019). Impact of population growth on unemployment in Nigeria: Dynamic OLS approach. Journal of Economics and Sustainable Development, 10(22), 79-89.
Maisiri, W., Darwish, H. & Van Dyk, L. (2019). An investigation of industry 4.0 skills requirements. South African Journal of Industrial Engineering, 30(3), 90-105.
Maphumulo, W.T. & Bhengu, B.R. (2019). Challenges of quality improvement in the healthcare of South Africa post-apartheid: A critical review. Curationis, 42(1), 1-9.
Mdluli, P. & Dunga, S. (2022). Determinants of poverty in South Africa using the 2018 general household survey data. Journal of Poverty, 26(3), 197-213.
Menter, I. (2024). The BRICS alliance and the impact of globalisation on teacher education worldwide. In Globalisation and Teacher Education in the BRICS Countries (pp. 3-26). Routledge.
Mujumdar, A., & Shadrin, A. (2021). Impact investment for BRICS cooperation on sustainable development. Asia-Pacific Social Science Review, 21(4), 26.
Mukherjee, P. (Ed.). (2022). Revisiting the Indian Financial Sector: Recent Issues and Perspectives. Springer Nature.
Nach, M. & Ncwadi, R. (2024). BRICS economic integration: Prospects and challenges. South African Journal of International Affairs, 31(2), 151-166.
Nayak, M. S. D. P., & Narayan, K. A. (2019). Strengths and weaknesses of online surveys. Technology, 6(7), 0837-2405053138.
Neely, A.H. & Ponshunmugam, A. (2019). A qualitative approach to examining health care access in rural South Africa. Social Science & Medicine, 230, 214-221.
Neuman, W. L. (2014). Social research methods: Qualitative and quantitative approaches. Boston: Pearson.
Ngubane, M., Mndebele, S. & Ilesanmi, K.D. (2023) Is South African economic growth sufficient for achieving the NDP unemployment target by 2030?. In Mbali Conference 2023 Proceedings (p. 561).
Nkhumeleni, M., Stiegler, N. & Ogujiuba, K. (2022). Interaction of Unemployment, Socioeconomic Factors and Demographic Dividend in South Africa: Issues and Policy Options. International Journal of Economics and Financial Issues, 12(5), 95-105.
Pasara, M.T. & Garidzirai, R. (2020). Causality effects among gross capital formation, unemployment and economic growth in South Africa. Economies, 8(2), p.26.
Plagerson, S., Patel, L., Hochfeld, T. & Ulriksen, M.S. (2019). Social policy in South Africa: Navigating the route to social development. World Development, 113, 1-9.
Preet, S. (2015). Developing the next generation. BRICS Business Magazine.
Pretorius, D. (2020). A Morphogenetic Approach to Social Development. Mistra Urban Futures: Göteborg, Sweden.
Ramokgopa, D. (2021). Tackling South Africa's Infrastructure Deficit: The Role of Development Finance Institutions. African perspectives Global insights.
Rensburg, I., Motala, S., & David, S. A. (2015). Learning mobility and internationalisation of higher education: economic and policy implications for BRICS nations. International Journal of Education Economics and Development, 6(3), 262-278.
Rust, F.C., Wall, K., Smit, M.A. & Amod, S. (2021). South African infrastructure condition-an opinion survey for the SAICE Infrastructure Report Card. Journal of the South African Institution of Civil Engineering, 63(2), 35-46.
Shubin, V. (2018). South Africa in the BRICS: Last but not Least. In BRICS and Global Governance (pp. 223-241). Routledge.
Soko, Y. (2023). South Africa’s saving and economic development linkage: Casual relationship examination. Journal of Developing Economies (JDE), 8(2).
South African Government News Agency. (2018, January 20). BRICS commits to international peace, security in MENA. https://www.sanews.gov.za/southafrica/bricscommits-international-peace-security-mena
STATS SA. (2024, January 15). Economic wrap-up for June 2024. Available: https://www.statssa.gov.za/?p=17364.
Strategy for BRICS Economic Partnership. (2015, December 20). Partnership strategy. https://en.brics2015.ru/load/381830&ved=2ahUKEwj6kZel7kfqA
Tandon, A.A. & Slobodchikoff, M.O. (2024). Cooperation between India and the BRICS: A Challenge to the Global Liberal Order. In The Sources of Great Power Competition (pp. 131-144). Routledge.
Thompson, G. (2017). BRICS: An Anti-Capitalist Critique, by Patrick Bond and Ana Garcia, eds. International Journal: Canada’s Journal of Global Policy Analysis, 71(4), 659-661. https://doi.org/10.1177/0020702016688393 (Original work published 2016).
Thompson, L. & De Wet, P.T. (2020). BRICS civil society initiatives: Towards the inclusion of affected communities in collective development?. In Affectedness And Participation In International Institutions (pp. 159-178). Routledge.
Tsaurai, K. (2025). Impact of Infrastructure Development on Foreign Direct Investment in BRICS Countries. Journal of Risk and Financial Management, 18(3), 152. https://doi.org/10.3390/jrfm18030152.
Vadra, R. (2017). Knowledge economy in BRICS: A case of South Africa. Journal of the knowledge economy, 8(4), 1229-1240.
Watt, N. F., Gomez, E. J., & McKee, M. (2014). Global health in foreign policy—and foreign policy in health? Evidence from the BRICS. Health policy and planning, 29(6), 763-773.
